Cardinal Reinhard Marx has taken an important step toward Gospel equality by declaring that priests who support women’s ordination are no longer automatically excluded from becoming bishops.
I welcome his courageous acknowledgment that the Church must reconsider its exclusion of women from ordained ministry. His willingness to question longstanding arguments for an exclusively male priesthood is a hopeful sign that the Spirit is moving within the institutional Church.
But I would ask Cardinal Marx a deeper question: If men who support women’s ordination can become bishops, why can’t women who are already called, prepared, and serving God’s people be recognized as priests and bishops?
For twenty years, I have served as a Roman Catholic woman priest and bishop in the movement for women’s ordination. I have witnessed women proclaim the Gospel, preside at Eucharist, anoint the sick, accompany the dying, and lead inclusive Catholic communities where everyone is welcome at the table.
We are not waiting for permission to respond to God’s call. We are already living the change we seek.
Cardinal Marx raises a fundamental theological question: Are we recognizing all the gifts God has bestowed upon the people of God, or are we excluding half the Church from sacramental leadership simply because they are women?
Jesus did not establish a discipleship of inequality. He welcomed women as disciples, entrusted Mary Magdalene with proclaiming the Resurrection, and challenged religious structures that excluded people from full participation in God’s reign.
The early Christian communities included women who exercised significant leadership, including Phoebe, a deacon and benefactor of the church at Cenchreae, and Junia, whom Paul describes as prominent among the apostles.
Their witness reminds us that women’s leadership is not a modern invention. It is part of our Christian heritage.
Cardinal Marx’s comments, together with Archbishop Josef Grünwidl of Vienna’s recent expression of support for women’s ordination, suggest that important conversations are opening among Catholic leaders.
But dialogue must lead to action.
I invite Cardinal Marx and Archbishop Grünwidl to join in calling upon Pope Leo XIV to initiate a Vatican-sponsored dialogue with Roman Catholic women priests, theologians, historians, and representatives of Catholic communities who support women’s ordination.
If a future Church council is necessary to address this question, why not begin preparing for it now?
The Association of Roman Catholic Women Priests has demonstrated that a renewed model of priestly ministry is possible—one rooted in Gospel equality, shared leadership, inclusive Eucharistic communities, and service rather than clerical privilege.
We envision a renewed Church where women and men and all genders minister together as equals, where every baptized person’s gifts are honored, and where leadership reflects the inclusive love of Jesus.
Cardinal Marx’s words offer hope. Yet the deeper challenge is not simply whether men who support women’s ordination can become bishops. It is whether the institutional Church will finally recognize that God’s call to priestly ministry cannot be limited by gender.
The Holy Spirit is not waiting for another committee, another study, or another generation.
The Spirit is already moving.
Women priests are already serving.
And the time for Gospel equality is now.
Rev. Dr. Bridget Mary Meehan, ARCWP
Bishop, Association of Roman Catholic Women Priests
Co-founder, People’s Catholic Seminary
Author and advocate for women’s equality in the Catholic Church
In response to AdVaticanum, November 13, 2026: “Cardinal Marx: Priests who support women’s ordination can now become bishops.”
https://advaticanum.com/article/cardinal-marx-priests-who-support-womens-ordination-can-now-become-bishops/


No comments:
Post a Comment