Translate

Monday, July 2, 2018

Josepha Madigan is Walking in the Footsteps of St. Brigid of Kildare



My response to the Irish Times article below: Kudos to Irish Minister Josepha Madigan for her deep faith and love for celebrating Eucharist. She has the spirit of St. Brigid in her soul and in her advocacy for equality. 
Yes, Ireland is ready for Women Priests!
If you are interested in finding out more about the path to ordination in the Association of Roman Catholic Women Priests and/or to join a community in Ireland exploring the path to equality in ministry in the Roman Catholic Church, contact me at sofiabmm@aol.com.  
Bridget Mary MEEHAN 

Josepha Madigan disappointed by ‘personal’ criticisms by Archbishop

Diarmuid Martin says Minister used absence of priest in her parish to ‘push agenda’

Tue, Jun 26, 2018, 16:01 Updated: Tue, Jun 26, 2018, 18:57


Minister for Culture, Heritage and the Gaeltacht Josepha Madigan said she is glad she took the opportunity to highlight what she said are inequalities in the Catholic Church.

Archbishop Diarmuid Martin had criticised Ms Madigan for “pushing an agenda” after she helped conduct a church service on Saturday when the parish priest failed to show.

Ms Madigan, who had assisted with the service in Mount Merrion in Dublin said afterwards the Church should ordain women and allow priests to marry. A failure to adapt would lead to a “severe decline” in church participation, she said in an interview on Monday.

In a strong rebuke of her comments, Archbishop Martin said on Tuesday the Minister had provoked “considerable distress” among churchgoers and ought to consider the upset she had caused.

“Many [parishioners] have contacted my office to express their hurt and upset at the Minister’s comments, as reported in the media,” he said in a statement.

Ms Madigan responded by saying she was disappointed by the personal nature of Archbishop Martin’s statement and said she intended to raise her concerns with Pope Francis when he visits Ireland next month.

“If I did not use this opportunity to highlight the inequalities I see in the Church then I would be turning a blind eye and I am not prepared to do that,” she said.

“The only agenda I am pushing is equality in the church just as I believe there should be equality in all facets of society. Although women play a role in the operations of the church, including my own parish, I believe the church has to change to reflect society as it is today,” she said.

Ms Madigan said she had never claimed to have “said mass”. “That was a newspaper headline. We simply carried on the service the best we could. I would ask this question of Bishop Martin; what advice would he have given me and my two colleagues last Saturday evening other than cancel the mass?”

 “He says I should listen to the views of those who disagree with my comments. I say it is the archbishop who should listen to the voice of 50 per cent of more of the congregation who are women and girls,” she said.

She said the weekend “incident” in the church was “not of my making. The circumstances just happened. I don’t know what the Archbishop expected us to do. There was a packed congregation. Were we just meant to leave the church? Not carry on with the service? I never claimed I said mass and would never attempt to do that.”
Quoting Edmund Burke, she added: “All it takes for evil to flourish is for good men to do nothing. If I didn’t address these issues when I have the platform then I wouldn’t live with myself in all good conscience”.

In his statement, Archbishop Martin there was no shortage of priests in the Archdiocese of Dublin but that there had simply been a misunderstanding regarding the parish of Mount Merrion service on Saturday evening.

“It is in no way correct to say that the Minister ‘said Mass’,” Archbishop Martin said.

“It is regrettable that Minister Madigan used this occasion to push a particular agenda. Her expressed view that a mix up in a Dublin parish on one particular Saturday evening should lead to the Universal Church changing core teachings is bizarre.

“Minister Madigan might consider listening to the voices of those people who disagree with her public comments, she might consider the hurt she has caused to parishioners who deem her actions deeply disrespectful.”

ARCC: Contemporary Catholic Belief in Action - The Bible's #MeToo Problem



One recent morning I happened across a scene of biblical violence. Flipping through Genesis, tracking down a quotation for a sermon, my eye caught on a chapter heading, "The Rape of Dinah." I paused and turned the phrase in my mind. My heart began to ache. I took a breath, sat back in my chair, and read the story of Dinah.

The Bible tells us that Dinah was the daughter of Leah, and devotes a single sentence to her rape: A prince of the region "saw her, seized her, and lay with her by force."

The rest of the chapter is devoted to the revenge carried out by Dinah's brothers, who barter her off to the prince as part of a strategy to attack his people. They succeed, and kill all the men of his nation. One can only imagine what happened to the women.
In the study bible I've dog-eared and underlined since seminary, I searched the book's notes for some mention of Dinah in all of this, and found one. Among historical references and exegesis, it simply read, "Dinah's reactions go unrecorded."

The myriad writers of our sacred stories, presumably all men, devote little time to women's perspectives. When women appear, we are often mute or nameless, pawns in men's games of war or violence, our reactions "unrecorded." But read between the lines of the Bible and you can detect the narratives of women deleted by uninterested editors, or left untold. Not all of these stories are of sexual assault or abuse, but many are.

There is Tamar, whose half brother meticulously plans her rape, calling in a crony to assist in the scheming. Her father, King David, is angry, but, "would not punish him, because he loved him." Sounds like a story I've heard before - especially considering David has some issues of his own, placing Bathsheba's husband on the front lines of war so that he could marry her himself.

Bathsheba's response to all of this? Unrecorded. She sleeps with the king with no reference to her consent, or lack of it.
There's also the almost unreadable story in Judges 19 of the Levite who pushes his concubine outside the walls of the house to be gang-raped by a lawless mob. By the morning she is dead; the Levite later mutilates her body.

The women of the Bible would be just as unsurprised as I am by the allegations against Harvey Weinstein, Eric Schneiderman or any of their compatriots. They would know, as I have come to realize, that the more vulnerable you are - a child, a woman of color, a foreigner, a slave or a concubine, a transgender man or woman - the more you are singled out to be used and discarded.

Christians owe a debt to scholars like Delores S. Williams and Phyllis Trible who have approached these texts from the victims' perspectives. Dr. Trible labels such stories "texts of terror." But rarely are these stories told in our churches. When we remember that a third or more of the women sitting in our pews have been sexually assaulted and the majority of them have been sexually harassed, the absence of biblical women's stories is telling.

People of all genders in our pews have been subjected to a range of abuses including childhood sexual abuse, while almost half of transgender individuals report being sexually assaulted. I would not wish to have these stories read from the lectern as a simple matter of course (and they certainly should not be held up as Gospel). But of all the Bible's stories, tragically, these "texts of terror" may be more resonant than any others when it comes to the heartbreaking, quotidian violence of the lives of women and gender and sexual minorities.

The muting of the #MeToos of the Bible is a direct reflection of the culture of silence at work in our congregations. An assumption is woven into our sacred texts: that the experiences of women don't matter. If religious communities fail to tell stories that reflect the experience of the women of our past, we will inevitably fail to address the sense of entitlement, assumption of superiority and lust for punishment carried through those stories and inherited by men of the present.

Recently, I attended sexual boundaries training for pastors. The workshop was largely focused on avoiding certain behaviors. "Leave the door to your office open during counseling sessions," we were told. "Don't visit congregants' homes alone." While these are all good and necessary practices that protect congregants and clergy members from harm, I await the day when we will robustly address the roots of abuse.

Statistically, perpetrators do not lurk in shadowy corners, waiting to pounce. They are men who have a hint of power, or wish they did, who understand women in much the same way so many of the stories of the Bible do - as objects to be penetrated, traded, bought or sold. They are sitting in our pews, or, sometimes, standing in our pulpits.

Abuse takes place when one person fails to see the humanity of another, taking what he wants in order to experience control, disordered intimacy or power. It is the symptom of an illness that is fundamentally spiritual: a kind of narcissism that allows him to focus only on sating his need, blind to the pain of the victim. This same narcissism caused the editors of our sacred stories to limit the rape of Dinah to only nine words in a book of thousands.
Refraining from troubling behaviors is not enough; abusive narcissism must be unraveled through a transformation of heart and mind. A shift in the larger culture depends on putting the stories of women front and center. We must create space for them to be heard, not only by women but also by men, who are steeped in a culture that valorizes those behaviors. Seeing women as the rightful owners of their own bodies depends, first, on encountering women as fellow humans.

If I were preaching the story of Dinah, I might simply ask, "How do you think she felt?" It's a question that some men have never considered. Though some abusers are beyond the reach of compassion, I have in my work as a pastor witnessed the ways hearts can open when someone tells a story. It is empathy, not regulations, that will create a different vision for masculinity in our nation, rooted in love instead of dominance. But transformation happens only in the hard light of truth. When we silence the stories of Dinah and her sisters, perpetrators continue to violate. And those who are victimized? Their reactions go unrecorded.


Emily M.D. Scott is a Lutheran pastor and the founder of St. Lydia's Dinner Church in Brooklyn, who is starting new faith community in Baltimore.

Sunday, July 1, 2018

Upper Room Inclusive Catholic Community Liturgy - July 1, 2018 - No Walls in the Kin-dom



Donna Rougeux, ARCWP, led the Upper Room liturgy with the theme: “No walls in the kin-dom.” 

This theme reminds us that the walls, labels , categories, boxes created by humans interfere with the pure reflection of  God’s love in us, around us and through us.  To symbolize a kin-dom with no walls, today we will forgo receiving the stole. Although the Upper Room is part of a movement that is committed to a non-clerical companionship of equals, today we want to be mindful of the clerical boundaries and walls that exist in the larger church as we leave the stoles on the friendship table.  

Donna’s homily starter is printed below the Gospel.

First Reading: Peace by Edwina Gateley

There is violence everywhere.
No one can escape the relentless news of
War, bombings and shootings,
Storms, fire, looting,
And myriad scenes
Of human pain and suffering.
It is our global environment.
We are surrounded.

But there is another place
Which we surround,
And no one or thing
Can violate.

Deep tucked within
The human soul
There is a silent harbor-
A dark, secret place
To which everyone of us
(Would we be aware)
Has freedom of access.

It is a small but powerful space,
A still-point,
Waiting for recognition
And habitation.

We can hide there
As in a town
Preparing for a resurrection
To thrust us forward,
Proclaiming to our world:
Yes, there is peace!
Yes, peace lives!

See-here-taste!

Peace waits only
To be known.

Gospel Reading

Mark 5:21-43

When Jesus had crossed again to the other shore in the boat, a large crowd gathered, and he stayed by the lakeside.

Then one of the synagogue officials, Jairus by name, came up and, seeing Jesus, fell down and pleaded earnestly, saying, “My little daughter is desperately sick. Come and lay your hands on her to make her better and save her life.” Jesus went with him and a large crowd followed, pressing from all sides.

Now there was a woman who had suffered from hemorrhages for twelve years; after long and painful treatment from various doctors, she had spent all she had without getting better- in fact, she was getting worse. She had heard about Jesus, and she came up behind him in the crowd and touched his cloak. “If I can touch even his hem,” she had told herself, “I will be well again.” Immediately the flow of blood dried up and she felt in her body that she was healed of her affliction.

Immediately aware that healing power had gone out from him, Jesus turned to the crowd and said, “Who touched my clothes?”

The disciples said, “You see how the crowd is pressing you, and yet you say, ‘Who touched me?’”

But Jesus continued to look around to see who had done it. Then the woman came forward, frightened and trembling because she knew what had
happened to her, and she fell at Jesus’ feet and told him the whole truth. “My daughter,” Jesus said, “your faith has saved you; go in peace, and be free of your affliction.”

While Jesus was still speaking, some people arrived from the house of the synagogue official to say, “Your daughter is dead. Why put the Teacher to any further trouble?”

But Jesus overheard the remark and said to the official: “Do not be afraid. Just believe.” Jesus allowed no one to follow him except Peter and James an James’ brother John.

They came to the official’s house and Jesus noticed all the commotion, with people weeping and wailing unrestrainedly. Jesus went in and said to them, “Why all this commotion and crying? The child is not dead, but asleep.” At this they began to ridicule him, and he told everyone to leave.

Jesus took the child’s mother and father and his own companions and entered the room where the child lay. Taking her hand, he said to her, “Talitha koum!” Which means, “Little girl, get up” Immediately the girl, who was twelve years old got up and began to walk about.

At this they were overcome with astonishment. Jesus gave the family strict orders not to let anyone know about it and told them to give the little girl something to eat.

Donna’s Homily starter:
Today’s gospel reading is a story sandwiched in another story that pictures Jesus healing a woman and a twelve-year-old girl. Both stories involve crossing boundaries that existed in the religious world during the time these stories were written. These boundaries had to do with being clean or unclean. The woman who touched the hem of Jesus’ cloak was considered unclean for twelve years because she had been hemorrhaging. She crossed a religious boundary when she touched Jesus’ cloak. The Jewish law said that she would make anyone she touched unclean and she most likely had been living in isolation during the twelve years of her bleeding due to this purity law. She dared to cross this boundary and was met with a very unusual response. She was immediately healed! This story adds to the drama when Jesus asks who touched his cloak and points to the gospel message of a free-flowing healing presence that comes from God. Instead of being stopped and sent back into isolation Jesus says to the woman “My daughter, your faith has saved you; go in peace and be free of your affliction,”

Jesus crossed another purity boundary by touching the body of a twelve-year-old girl who the people believed was dead. Touching a dead body was considered an act of making someone unclean. Jesus not only touched the little girl he erased the boundary between life and death by healing the little girl.

What can we learn from these stories about boundaries, borders, people made laws, policies and walls? Boundaries, laws and policies have a purpose and become important in keeping us healthy and safe. There is a time an place for rules, laws and boundaries. I read a parenting book once that gives a way to navigate keeping healthy boundaries as a parent. The book describes parents who are brick walls, parents who are jelly fish and parents who are backbones. The brick wall parents have rules for their children that are strict and unmovable. The jelly fish parents basically have no rules and the backbone parents have rules that bend and are flexible. The point of the book was to encourage parents to be backbone parents.

Using this analogy and the gospel message what does a kin-dom with no walls look like? How do we navigate systems, families and communities filled with brick wall, jellyfish and backbone rules, laws and boundaries? 

The first reading today points to an answer to these questions. The poem suggests that there is a place where “no one or thing can violate…it is a small but powerful space, a still-point, waiting for recognition and habitation.” I think this is our conscience or our God voice deep inside of us. It is a place we need to visit often to find peace in a world of suffering, wall building and isolation. We must find peace within ourselves before we can bring peace to the world and be part of building the kin-dom with no walls.

Jesus gives us an example of what that kin-dom looks like. It is a place that offers unconditional love and healing to all people. It is a place where the law that is most important is written on our hearts. We must go to the small still God voice within us often so that we can be the change we want to see. We must allow the free-flowing love of God to be borderless and without boundaries. We must build a kin-dom with no walls.